Meal Replacement Protein Shake Comparison

I love meal replacement shakes!  They're the easiest thing I can make/eat for breakfast, and they are down-right tasty!  I especially like that they can be prepared and taken with you if you are in a hurry.  I have tried so many different kinds, and I have charted a comparison for the 10 most popular ones.  If you're considering a meal replacement or protein shake and have no idea where to start, I hope this chart can help you decide which shake is right for you.

Of all the shakes I have tried, ViSalus is by far my personal favorite!  The taste is amazingly sweet for a shake with so few carbs!  Some of the tastier shakes only taste so good because they are loaded up with sugar.  If you're trying a low-carb lifestyle (generally under 20g carbs daily), stay away from both Shakeology and Slimfast as they will both use up more than half of your daily carbs by the end of breakfast.

Some of these shakes may contain soy, which some people believe is bad for PCOS.  Go here to see why soy is not bad for PCOS.  Not convinced?  Take a look at this article!  Need one more?  Try here!  But if you're still not willing to risk it, I have included data to show you which ones do contain soy as a primary protein source if you are trying to avoid it.  Obviously, any person can have adverse reactions to any food, so always monitor yourself and what you are consuming.  I personally have no issues with soy and consume small quantities (generally under 10g) almost daily.  For me, it has not hindered weight loss or fertility.  It should also be noted that the FDA recommends the daily intake of soy to not exceed 25 grams.

 

BRAND (Click to View)	PRICE (monthly)	TASTE	CALORIES (per serving)	PRIMARY PROTEINS	PROTEIN (grams)	NET CARBS (grams)
ViSalus	$49.99		90	Soy & Whey	12g	2g
Designer Whey	$24.99		100	Whey	18g	6g
Shakeology	$129.99		130	Whey & Pea	16g	11g
Slimfast Protein	$39.90		110	Whey	7g	11g
Quest Protein	$37.78		100	Whey & Casein	22g	3g
Dream Protein	$29.22		86	Whey	20g	3.4g
Syntrax Matrix	$29.95		110	Whey & Casein	23g	2g
Pure Protein	$27.99		150	Whey	25g	8g
Isopure	$42.79		210	Whey	50g	0g
Ensure	$34.99		130	Whey & Casein	20g	9g

*For the sake of simplicity, I only rated the Vanilla flavor of each brand.  The price for each shake is an average and may change over time.  I rated the taste according to my own personal palate, which means that some flavors that I find enjoyable, others may not (and vice versa).  Calories, protein, and carbs are all established before adding additional ingredients (such as milk, almond milk, fruit, veggies, etc.).